The line items most people never add up, from equity to parental leave
Base pay is the figure everyone sets side by side, and it tells you the least. According to Deloitte's 2025 study of 7,500 women, only 5% plan to stay at their current employer beyond five years. That means you'll likely be weighing another offer sooner than you expect, so it pays to learn how to total up the full package now.
Imagine the stronger offer sits $20,000 above the other on base. For illustration, a 20% bonus target rather than 10% on a $200,000 salary is worth $20,000 a year all by itself, and a 6% retirement match instead of 3% adds another $6,000. Even before reaching the second paragraph of the offer letter, a lower salary figure may already be the stronger deal for a Phoenix-area hire.
Tally sheet
Rate the weaker option. Tick each item as a yes or a no, and then count the affirmatives.
1. A bonus target that represents a bigger portion of salary matters here, especially since the firm reached or exceeded that goal in both of the previous two years in Greater Phoenix, Arizona.
2. The retirement match is richer, vests faster, or does both.
3. Equity is part of the deal, and you understand the vesting timeline, the strike price or most recent valuation, and what becomes of unvested shares should you be let go.
4. Parental or caregiver leave runs longer and is paid in full, and people at your level really use it.
5. Compared with the rival offer, your job title and the person you'd report to both carry more seniority.
6. Your offer letter in Phoenix should spell out the remote or hybrid arrangement in writing, rather than relying only on a promise made over the phone.
7. Once premiums, deductibles and family coverage are factored in, health insurance costs you less each month.
8. Vacation and personal days are more substantial, and the managers who would hire you in Gilbert or Scottsdale really do use theirs.
9. The pay band extends beyond your starting figure, so your next two raises won't run into a ceiling.
Step ten A signing bonus or retention payment makes up for what you forfeit by switching, such as an unpaid bonus or unvested shares.
Reading your score
0 to 3: The larger number wins outright. The offer with the lower number is, in fact, lower on pay. Take the higher base and negotiate the remaining gaps upward, because the difference you just measured is your argument.
4 to 6: It's closer than it appears. The $20,000 is genuine, but so is much of what the smaller offer includes. Assign a dollar amount to every yes you marked, then set the two sums next to each other on the same page. Plenty of people find the gap shrinks below $5,000 in year one and flips by year three.
7 to 10: The lower-paying offer is actually the more valuable one for you. What you have is a more thoughtfully assembled benefits package, even though its headline pay is smaller. Base is the simplest line to change, so go after it.
Next actions
If you scored 0 to 3, return to the smaller offer and say: "I'd like to accept, and I need the base to reach X for the move to make sense." Asking costs you nothing but the question.
If you scored 4 to 6, build a two-column sheet pricing every line, then put one question to each employer: "Is there room to move on the item where you're behind?" Whoever answers with a concrete number is showing you how badly they want you.
If you scored 7 to 10, take the richer package and ask that the base difference be partly closed in cash at signing, with the rest addressed at a dated review. "Could we close half that gap at signing and revisit the remainder at six months?"
Which offer scored higher, and were you surprised? Share your result with us.