Seven pieces of "wisdom" senior women wish they had ignored

Call her Dana. Carla isn't a real member or client; she's a figure built from several accounts. She's 46, a senior vice president, and she's out to lunch with a 31-year-old manager from her team who has just asked the question Carla was asked at that age: "What's the one piece of advice you'd give me?"

Carla is stuck on this one and cannot move past it. Each piece of guidance she received at 31 came from someone more senior, meant well, and turned out to be mistaken, and she followed every bit of it. She is weighing which of these habits hurt her most, so she knows which one to flag first for the manager. Her list runs to seven items. Three still make her angry.

Option one. Stay out of sight and let your work do the talking

The cost is that your work goes unnoticed. Advocacy comes from people, and in Carla's situation the speaker was her boss, who claimed her work as his own across four years in Phoenix. Over that whole stretch, only one promotion came her way. He got two. According to a 2025 McKinsey and LeanIn report, sponsors are in place for 31% of entry-level women but for 45% of men. Staying quiet and waiting is how you wind up among the 69% without one.

Option two. Hold off on applying unless you satisfy every listed qualification.

Between ages 33 and 40, she passed on six openings she never pursued. Tara Mohr's survey for Harvard Business Review found that women often skip jobs they feel underqualified for mainly because they read the posted requirements as hard rules, not because they lack confidence. Carla read them as rules. The men who secured those six roles saw them as aspirations to pursue.

Option three. Be thankful for the opportunity

Each offer left her so thankful that she took whatever figure was first put forward. Research from Berkeley Haas, published in 2023, shows 54% of women bargained over their latest offer against 44% of men, yet women's pay still came out lower. Gratitude is a feeling, not a pay strategy, and the people who told her to feel it weren't the ones signing her paychecks.

What seasoned executives usually suggest

Senior women in the Valley bring up the remaining four whenever they swap stories. Phrases like "wait your turn" assume a line exists and that someone is keeping track of it. Warnings such as "don't be too ambitious" are rarely if ever given to a man over 40 during his review. "Just be yourself," which is hollow without the second half: "and find out what that costs here." And the one senior women rank as worst most often: "If you're good, they'll notice." They will notice. Recognizing a problem and doing something about it are different, and the years lost between those two steps can add up to a decade.

Leaders also offer a more generous remark in return. Not one piece of this advice was intended to injure her. It came from people who got where they were by a different route and assumed the road was still open. The advice isn't a lie. What she received is a map that no longer matches the terrain.

The verdict

Your answer depends on who you were at 31. If you already spoke up freely, keeping quiet won't work for you. Someone who was already careful will pay the steepest price for "match every requirement," since she will obey it to the letter. Carla tells the manager the thing she wishes she'd been told: "Assume nobody is keeping score for you, and keep it yourself."

Vote slip

Which of these three, A, B or C, has been the most expensive for you? Send your letter to the Phoenix chapter and we'll publish the results next month. If the worst counsel you received isn't among these, add it to the list too. Seven is the cutoff only because that is how many the layout allows.