The case for discretion, the case for disclosure, and the middle path

WebMD Health Services reports that close to half of women managers and executives keep their menopause symptoms hidden from colleagues, and roughly one in three has considered leaving a job because of them. Those figures describe a familiar figure: a woman juggling a medical change and a professional reputation at once, with no guidebook for either. Choosing whether to speak up is less about personal courage and more about tactics, and the best choice depends on where you stand. Work through the ten questions here to see where you stand, starting with your own circumstances.

Your score

Respond with a yes or a no to each prompt, then count how many yeses you gave.

1. A close coworker would probably pick up on how my symptoms have altered the way I come across at work.

2. Over the last quarter, a symptom has forced me to cancel, shorten or reschedule something that mattered to me in Phoenix or the Valley.

3. When it comes to protecting personal details, my manager has a reliable history.

4. Somewhere in my company, a senior woman has spoken candidly about menopause, caring for family or her own health, and nothing visible has been taken from her for it.

5. There is a written policy on menopause, health or flexible working that I could show someone at my company.

6. For the next half year, no performance review, promotion decision or reorganization touches my role.

7. I can name a concrete change I'd like, like a cooler desk, a flexible start time or permission to keep my camera off, instead of only hoping people will understand.

8. I am confident that the colleague I would tell will keep it to themselves and not discuss it when I am absent.

9. Keeping my symptoms out of sight takes more out of me than it would to explain them just once.

Item ten I could lay out my circumstances in two sentences and not feel the need to say sorry.

Questions 1, 2, 7, 9 and 10 show how much hiding your symptoms is actually costing you. Questions 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8 gauge how safe it is to stop concealing. You need to read both sets to make a sound decision.

Reading your result

Scores from zero to three mean your discretion is working as intended. Staying quiet is either costing you very little, the ground beneath you is still unstable, or possibly both. Keeping a health matter private while you wait for your workplace to change is a sensible choice and reflects no weakness on your part.

A total of four to six places you on the middle path. Hiding your symptoms is starting to take a toll, and there is at least one person nearby you can rely on. Most senior women in the Valley land here, and this band offers the most room to maneuver.

A score of seven to ten means that telling people has become the less costly option. Hiding is now costing you more than explaining would, and the circumstances are in place for you to do it well.

What to do next

A score of zero to three suggests asking for the change you need while leaving your diagnosis unmentioned. "I do my best work in a cooler room, and a nine-thirty start on Tuesdays would help" needs no medical background, and many managers will agree without asking for more.

At four to six, choose one trusted person to tell on purpose, and include a specific request with it. I'm dealing with some menopause symptoms. They are managed at the moment, and one thing that would really help is keeping my camera off for the early calls." Two sentences, one clear request, no apology, and the request tells them exactly what they can do next.

Seven to ten: Share it the way you would share any operational detail, then carry on. Whatever tone you model is the one others are likely to adopt after you. If your employer currently lacks a policy, you could be the person whose request prompts one to be written.

Your result Share your result with your chapter group and see how many women two seats over are on the same page.